American Marketing Association
View my basket
Atypon Link logo

You have no access to this article

Scholarly Research in Marketing: Exploring the “4 Eras” of Thought Development


Author(s): William L. Wilkie | Elizabeth S. Moore
doi: 10.1509/jppm.22.2.116.17639
Prev | Table of contents | Next
 
View PDF article (213 K) View PDF with links (223 K)
Email this link
 What is RSS?
Trouble viewing articles as PDF?
 
  Journal of Public Policy & Marketing
 
Print ISSN: 0743-9156  |  Electronic ISSN: 1547-7207
Volume: 22 | Issue: 2
Cover date: Fall 2003
Page(s): 116-146
 
 
  Keywords
 
marketing thought, marketing scholarship, societal dimensions of marketing, historial analysis, marketing and society
 
  Abstract

Today’s body of marketing thought is expanding geometrically, pushing frontiers in numerous domains—quantitatively, behaviorally, strategically—with much enhanced technology and on an increasingly globalized basis. As this pushes forward on many fronts, however, it is also worthwhile to ask what is in danger of being left behind. What is the benefit, if any, of discerning the roots of this field? On the basis of an extended look across the last century of marketing thought, this article paints a wide-ranging portrait of (1) the general course that has been taken by the body of marketing thought over its “4 Eras” and (2) how the treatment of societal dimensions of marketing has fared during each period. On the basis of these findings, the authors pose several key issues for further consideration by interested thinkers concerned with the progress of marketing scholarship.

 
  Author(s) affiliations
 
1. Aloysius and Eleanor Nathe Professor of Marketing, University of Notre Dame
2. Associate Professor of Marketing, University of Notre Dame
 
  This article has been cited by:
1.
 
Biotechnology marketing: Insider and outsider views.
Päivi Eriksson, Heidi Rajamäki.
Journal of Commercial Biotechnology
CrossRef
2.
 
Vulnerability and Resilience in Natural Disasters: A Marketing and Public Policy Perspective.
Stacey Menzel Baker.
Journal of Public Policy & Marketing |  28 |  1 |  114-123
View Header/Abstract | View PDF article (75 KB) | PDF Plus (84 KB) 
3.
 
Reflections on The History of Marketing Thought.
Eric H. Shaw.
Journal of Historical Research in Marketing |  1 |  2 |  330-345
CrossRef
4.
 
Paths to marketing's future: a sub-first tier GATORE principle perspective.
B. Nathaniel Carr II.
European Journal of Marketing |  42 |  11/12 |  1145-1155
CrossRef
5.
 
Publishing on publishing: streams in the literature.
Michael Jay Polonsky.
European Business Review |  20 |  5 |  401-420
CrossRef
6.
 
Contemporary Marketing Practices research program: a review of the first decade.
Roderick J. Brodie, Nicole E. Coviello, Heidi Winklhofer.
Journal of Business & Industrial Marketing |  23 |  2 |  84
CrossRef
7.
 
Stephan C. Henneberg, Stefanos Mouzas.
Creating and managing superior customer value |  14 |  99
CrossRef
8.
 
Marketing with integrity: ethics and the service-dominant logic for marketing.
Andrew V. Abela, Patrick E. Murphy.
Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science |  36 |  1 |  39
CrossRef
9.
 
The American Marketing Association's 2004 Definition of Marketing: Perspectives on Its Implications for Scholarship and the Role and Responsibility of Marketing in Society.
Gregory T. Gundlach.
Journal of Public Policy & Marketing |  26 |  2 |  243-250
View Header/Abstract | View PDF article (66 KB) | PDF Plus (72 KB) 
10.
 
Marketing as Constructive Engagement.
Clifford J. Shultz II.
Journal of Public Policy & Marketing |  26 |  2 |  293-301
View Header/Abstract | View PDF article (193 KB) | PDF Plus (198 KB) 
11.
 
A Responsibilities Framework for Marketing as a Professional Discipline.
Shelby D. Hunt.
Journal of Public Policy & Marketing |  26 |  2 |  277-283
View Header/Abstract | View PDF article (62 KB) | PDF Plus (66 KB) 
12.
 
What Does the Definition of Marketing Tell Us About Ourselves?.
William L. Wilkie, Elizabeth S. Moore.
Journal of Public Policy & Marketing |  26 |  2 |  269-276
View Header/Abstract | View PDF article (65 KB) | PDF Plus (70 KB) 
13.
 
A Comment on Selected Wilkie and MooreInspired Commentaries in The Sages Speak.
John F. Gaski.
Journal of Public Policy & Marketing |  26 |  1 |  126-130
View Header/Abstract | View PDF article (52 KB) | PDF Plus (58 KB) 
14.
 
Continuing Challenges to Scholarly Research in Marketing.
William L. Wilkie.
Journal of Public Policy & Marketing |  26 |  1 |  131-134
View Header/Abstract | View PDF article (51 KB) | PDF Plus (55 KB) 
15.
 
Five Phases in a Personal Journey Through the Troubled Waters of Academic Values in a World of Business: Where's the Beef?.
Morris B. Holbrook.
Journal of Public Policy & Marketing |  26 |  1 |  135-138
View Header/Abstract | View PDF article (48 KB) | PDF Plus (52 KB) 
16.
 
The Wroe river: the canyon carved by Alderson.
Terry Beckman.
European Business Review |  19 |  6 |  452
CrossRef
17.
 
The diaspora has already begun.
Gerard Hastings.
Marketing Intelligence & Planning |  25 |  2 |  117
CrossRef
18.
 
Placing Wroe Alderson's contributions to buyer behavior in historical perspective.
Robert D. Tamilia.
European Business Review |  19 |  6 |  468
CrossRef
19.
 
A marketing paradox.
Mark E. Hill, John McGinnis, Jane Cromartie.
Marketing Intelligence & Planning |  25 |  7 |  652
CrossRef
20.
 
Publishing in socially oriented journals – the state of play in Asia.
Michael Jay Polonsky, John D. Mittelstaedt.
Asia Pacific Journal of Marketing and Logistics |  18 |  1 |  61
CrossRef
21.
 
An examination of the globalisation of authorship in publishing in 20 leading marketing journals.
Michael Jay Polonsky, Romana Garma, John D. Mittelstaedt.
European Business Review |  18 |  6 |  437
CrossRef
22.
 
Macromarketing: origins, development, current status and possible future direction.
Stanley J. Shapiro.
European Business Review |  18 |  4 |  307
CrossRef
23.
 
Marketing and consumerism: A response to O'Shaughnessy and O'Shaughnessy.
Andrew V. Abela.
European Journal of Marketing |  40 |  1/2 |  5
CrossRef
24.
 
Marketing Renaissance: Opportunities and Imperatives for Improving Marketing Thought, Practice, and Infrastructure.
Stephen W. Brown, , Frederick E. Webster Jr., , Jan-Benedict E.M. Steenkamp, , William L. Wilkie, , Jagdish N. Sheth, , Rajendra S. Sisodia, , Roger A. Kerin, , Deborah J. MacInnis, , Leigh McAlister, , Jagmohan S. Raju, , et al..
Journal of Marketing |  69 |  4 |  1-25
Citation | View PDF article (184 KB) | PDF Plus (200 KB) 
25.
 
Marketing Scholarship, Intellectual Leadership, and the Zeitgeist.
Alan R. Andreasen .
Journal of Public Policy & Marketing |  24 |  1 |  133-136
Citation | View PDF article (54 KB) | PDF Plus (56 KB) 
26.
 
Asian Management Education: Some Twenty-First-Century Issues.
David B. Montgomery .
Journal of Public Policy & Marketing |  24 |  1 |  150-154
Citation | View PDF article (58 KB) | PDF Plus (60 KB) 
27.
 
When Policies and Marketing Systems Explode: An Assessment of Food Marketing in the War-Ravaged Balkans and Implications for Recovery, Sustainable Peace, and Prosperity.
Clifford J. Shultz II, , Timothy J. Burkink, , Bruno Grbac, , Nataša Renko .
Journal of Public Policy & Marketing |  24 |  1 |  24-37
View Header/Abstract | View PDF article (349 KB) | PDF Plus (277 KB) 
28.
 
Customer Orientation in the Context of Development Projects: Insights from the World Bank.
Debabrata Talukdar, , Sumila Gulyani, , Lawrence F. Salmen .
Journal of Public Policy & Marketing |  24 |  1 |  100-111
View Header/Abstract | View PDF article (96 KB) | PDF Plus (102 KB) 
29.
 
Ruminations on Theory and Research Scholarship in Marketing.
Robert A. Peterson .
Journal of Public Policy & Marketing |  24 |  1 |  127-130
Citation | View PDF article (69 KB) | PDF Plus (75 KB) 
30.
 
Evolution Versus Tradition in Marketing Systems: The Hong Kong Food-Retailing Experience.
Suk-Ching Ho .
Journal of Public Policy & Marketing |  24 |  1 |  90-99
View Header/Abstract | View PDF article (93 KB) | PDF Plus (98 KB) 
31.
 
Customer Advocacy: A New Era in Marketing?.
Glen L. Urban .
Journal of Public Policy & Marketing |  24 |  1 |  155-159
Citation | View PDF article (59 KB) | PDF Plus (59 KB) 
32.
 
Journal Evolution and the Development of Marketing.
Donald R. Lehmann .
Journal of Public Policy & Marketing |  24 |  1 |  137-142
Citation | View PDF article (61 KB) | PDF Plus (63 KB) 
33.
 
The Sages Speak ....
William L. Wilkie .
Journal of Public Policy & Marketing |  24 |  1 |  112-113
Citation | View PDF article (43 KB) | PDF Plus (45 KB) 
34.
 
A Dangerous Divergence: Marketing and Society.
Jagdish N. Sheth, , Rajendra S. Sisodia .
Journal of Public Policy & Marketing |  24 |  1 |  160-162
Citation | View PDF article (47 KB) | PDF Plus (49 KB) 
35.
 
Looking Backward—and Ahead.
Stanley J. Shapiro .
Journal of Public Policy & Marketing |  24 |  1 |  117-120
Citation | View PDF article (49 KB) | PDF Plus (51 KB) 
36.
 
Antiglobal Challenges to Marketing in Developing Countries: Exploring the Ideological Divide.
Terrence H. Witkowski .
Journal of Public Policy & Marketing |  24 |  1 |  7-23
View Header/Abstract | View PDF article (137 KB) | PDF Plus (144 KB) 
37.
 
Toward Insight and Relevance.
Leigh M. McAlister .
Journal of Public Policy & Marketing |  24 |  1 |  131-132
Citation | View PDF article (40 KB) | PDF Plus (43 KB) 
38.
 
Eras III and IV: My Reflections.
Richard Staelin .
Journal of Public Policy & Marketing |  24 |  1 |  146-149
Citation | View PDF article (52 KB) | PDF Plus (54 KB) 
39.
 
A Perspective on the Evolution of Marketing Management.
Frederick E. Webster Jr. .
Journal of Public Policy & Marketing |  24 |  1 |  121-126
Citation | View PDF article (60 KB) | PDF Plus (64 KB) 
40.
 
The Role Played by the Broadening of Marketing Movement in the History of Marketing Thought.
Philip Kotler .
Journal of Public Policy & Marketing |  24 |  1 |  114-116
Citation | View PDF article (46 KB) | PDF Plus (48 KB) 
41.
 
Exploring Marketing's Relationship to Society.
William L. Wilkie .
Journal of Public Policy & Marketing |  24 |  1 |  1-2
Citation | View PDF article (44 KB) | PDF Plus (45 KB) 
42.
 
Marketing Education as Bad Medicine for Society: The Gorilla Dances.
Morris B. Holbrook .
Journal of Public Policy & Marketing |  24 |  1 |  143-145
Citation | View PDF article (46 KB) | PDF Plus (48 KB) 
43.
 
Marketing social para el entorno sanitario: Una aplicación para los servicios de urgencias de los hospitales públicos.
Juan Miguel Rey Pino.
International Review on Public and Nonprofit Marketing |  1 |  2 |  43-56
CrossRef
44.
 
EU's competition policy and the GE-Honeywell merger fiasco: Transatlantic divergence and consumer and regulatory issues.
Syed Tariq Anwar.
Thunderbird International Business Review |  47 |  5 |  601
CrossRef
45.
 
Pasado, presente y futuro de las dimensiones pública y social en el desarrollo conceptual del marketing.
José Luis Vézquez Burguete.
International Review on Public and Nonprofit Marketing |  1 |  1 |  9-34
CrossRef